Catholic bishops in England and Wales say a new government bill could turn prayers, pastoral counseling, and parental advice into criminal acts.
Story Snapshot
- Archbishop John Sherrington warns the draft Conversion Practices Bill creates “uncertainty” around lawful pastoral care and family life.
- The bill defines “conversion practice” as any conduct meant to change or suppress someone’s sexual orientation or gender identity.
- The government says the law only targets abuse causing serious harm, comparing it to psychiatric injury like PTSD.
- Survivors told Parliament that decades of prayer sessions and exorcisms left them suicidal and hospitalized.
- The bill is still under review, meaning lawmakers could change it before it becomes law.
Bishops Say the Bill’s Reach Is Too Broad
Archbishop John Sherrington of Liverpool, who chairs the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of England and Wales on social justice, says the draft bill would create “uncertainty around lawful pastoral care by the Church, family life and open conversations that can take place in a range of social settings”. He says the bill “proposes to extend the legal definition of abusive practices in ways that threaten a person’s fundamental rights, including freedom of religion or belief and freedom of expression”.
The bishops specifically name parents among those who could face legal trouble. Sherrington’s statement says parents expressing “well-informed opinions” or making “well-intentioned statements” to their own children could fall under the bill’s scope. The bishops say they oppose abusive counseling “in all circumstances” but argue the bill’s current wording goes far beyond stopping actual abuse.
How the Draft Law Defines a Crime
The government’s draft bill defines a “conversion practice” as any conduct by a person meant to cause someone to have, not have, or believe they have or don’t have a certain sexual orientation, including conduct tied to transgender identity. That wording is broad enough to cover far more than clinical therapy. It could, in theory, touch sermons, private prayer, or a parent’s advice, though the bishops have not pointed to a specific sermon or conversation that has triggered a charge.
The government’s own equality assessment acknowledges the tension. It says the bill must balance protecting children with upholding parental rights and staying compatible with the European Convention on Human Rights, specifically the articles covering private family life and freedom of religion. That built-in balancing test suggests officials already anticipated objections like the ones the bishops are raising now.
Government Insists the Target Is Serious Harm, Not Speech
Ministers say the bill only criminalizes conduct that causes “serious harm” to someone’s physical or mental health, or “serious alarm or distress” that substantially disrupts daily life. The explanatory notes compare that harm threshold to psychiatric injury, naming post-traumatic stress disorder and clinical depression as examples. Officials argue this narrow focus means ordinary prayer or pastoral conversation would not qualify unless it produced injury on that scale.
Survivor testimony is driving much of the government’s case. A man named Ian Smith told Parliament’s Joint Committee that a decade of exorcisms and counseling aimed at changing his sexuality left him suicidal and led to a psychiatric hospital admission. A woman named Jayne described more than 20 years of religious conversion attempts, including exorcisms and hypnosis, that led to self-harm and repeated hospital stays.
Advocacy group Stonewall cites survey data showing 7% of LGBTQ+ people in the United Kingdom say they were offered or underwent conversion therapy, with that number nearly doubling to 13% among transgender respondents. Stonewall argues that most individual incidents fall below the bar for existing crimes like harassment or coercive control, even when the cumulative harm over years is severe. That is the core case for writing a new, broader law in the first place.
A Legal Fight Playing Out on Both Sides of the Atlantic
The clash echoes a similar fight in the United States. The Supreme Court recently struck down most of Colorado’s conversion therapy ban for licensed counselors in an 8-1 ruling, siding with a counselor who argued the law violated her free speech and religious rights. That case shows courts can and do narrow these bans when they reach too far into protected speech, giving the bishops a precedent to point toward even without a UK ruling yet.
No named prosecution, court case, or specific Catholic teaching has been shown to fall under the UK bill so far. The measure remains in pre-legislative scrutiny, meaning Parliament can still amend, narrow, or add exemptions before any final vote. Both the bishops’ warnings and the government’s survivor-backed case will likely keep shaping that process in the months ahead.
Sources:
middlesbrough-diocese.org.uk, gov.uk, gayety.com, humanists.uk, bbc.com, stonewall.org.uk, commonslibrary.parliament.uk, researchbriefings.files.parliament.uk, bu.edu
