Philosophy Cage Match: Whose Rights Rule?

The crux of the abortion debate is not a single empirical discovery about embryos; it is a collision between two moral frameworks that use different categories—human organism, moral subject, rights-holder, and dependent patient—to answer one question: when does a human being gain a right to life?

The Short Version

  • Two coherent but incompatible frameworks structure the dispute: intrinsic value tied to being a human organism versus rights grounded in bodily autonomy and developed capacities.
  • A prominent conservative argument holds that human life has intrinsic value, so abortion is presumptively wrong unless a strong justification defeats that value.
  • Judith Jarvis Thomson’s counter-case grants fetal personhood for argument’s sake yet separates a right to life from any right to use another person’s body.
  • Philosophers also debate developmental thresholds—consciousness, pain, viability—but none offers a consensus conversion from biological description to moral or legal personhood.
  • Law and policy often hinge less on metaphysics than on how conflicts of rights are mediated under uncertainty and risk.

Two Master Arguments, One Persistent Question

Start with the most influential conservative structure. It runs like this: it is wrong to destroy something with intrinsic value without adequate justification; human life has intrinsic value; therefore abortion is wrong unless a justification defeats that value. This view is intentionally secular in formulation—no scriptural premise appears in the syllogism—and it can explain why sleeping adults and patients in reversible comas retain full moral status despite diminished consciousness. In reputable summaries, the position is described as conservative and ascribing equal moral status to the fetus from conception. The argumentative strength here is clarity: it provides a bright line and a rationale for protecting vulnerable humans whose current capacities are limited.

Recent bioethics work attempts to refine the biological side of this claim by distinguishing stages of development. On one account, organismic fetal life—the integrated, developing human organism—carries intrinsic moral status, whereas the earliest embryo is treated as a “non-organismal human individual” with only extrinsic moral status until somatic integration obtains. This refinement aims to mark when a new individual human organism exists, resisting both the charge of “biological mysticism” and the sliding scale that ties status solely to consciousness.

Why Bodily Autonomy Does Not Disappear

Against this, Thomson’s canonical argument reframes the key inference. Even if a fetus has a right to life, that right does not automatically include a claim on another person’s bodily resources. Her famous thought experiment—the unconscious violinist tethered to your body for survival—sharpens the point: detaching yourself, though it foreseeably leads to the violinist’s death, need not violate his right to life because that right is not a right to your body. This is not a denial of fetal value; it is a boundary on what rights entail and on what others may be compelled to provide. In public philosophy and pedagogy, that separation—right to life versus entitlement to another’s body—remains one of the most resilient counters to conception-based bans.

Subsequent analysis has prodded the analogy’s limits. Unlike the violinist, pregnancy often follows actions that foreseeably create dependency and involves a biologically unique relationship; some argue those facts generate special obligations. Yet even sympathetic critiques tend to preserve Thomson’s core distinction: a right to life is not a right to be given the means of life by a specific other, leaving the pregnancy case to turn on whether and when special obligations arise that can override bodily autonomy claims.

Developmental Milestones and the Search for a Middle Way

For those uneasy with either pole, developmental thresholds offer a moderate route. Philosophers have proposed consciousness, the capacity to feel pain, and viability as morally salient moments—each attempting to anchor increasing moral weight in emerging capacities rather than in species membership alone. Moderate views often place the likely onset of pain-capable consciousness late in gestation, while acknowledging uncertainty and uneven maturation in fetal neurodevelopment. The attraction of these thresholds is intuitive gradation; the liability is conceptual slippage. A descriptive milestone does not, by itself, explain why it should be decisive for rights, nor how it interacts with the pregnant person’s concurrent claims.

This is why the dispute endures. Changing the criterion shifts the burden but does not dissolve the fundamental categories at issue. Emphasize organismic identity and you owe a theory of how rights press against bodily autonomy in hard cases. Emphasize autonomy or capacities and you owe a theory that protects clearly dependent or nonconscious humans—newborns, certain brain-injured patients—without arbitrariness. Both sides can be consistent; neither escapes trade-offs.

From Moral Status to Moral Conflict

Even the most polished conception-based argument, including those that specify organismic integration, typically concludes not with an absolute prohibition but with a defeasible presumption: abortion is wrong absent justification. That last clause bears the real weight. Once admitted, justifications must be sorted—self-defense when pregnancy threatens life, severe fetal anomaly, sexual coercion, catastrophic health risk. The Stanford Encyclopedia’s treatment underscores another live fault line: even if the fetus is granted a right to life, that right may not entail the right to use someone else’s body; a moral presumption against killing does not resolve enforceable obligations in bodily conflicts. Any move from moral status to legal prohibition requires a separate argument about the state’s authority to compel bodily service and how to adjudicate exceptions.

What Strong Evidence Supports—and What It Does Not

As a matter of documented philosophy, three claims are on firm ground. First, there is a fully secular, conservative argument that ties human moral status to being a living human organism and that treats abortion as presumptively wrong unless defeated by competing claims. Second, there is a rigorous body of analysis that separates a right to life from any right to the use of another’s body, thereby preserving a path to abortion’s permissibility even if fetal personhood is granted. Third, capacity-based and developmental milestones remain candidates for moral salience, especially in later gestation, but they do not enjoy disciplinary consensus as rights-conferring thresholds. What none of these establish is a knockdown conversion of biological facts into legal personhood, or a universal principle that settles all hard cases without remainder. The disagreement is philosophical, not empirical, at its core.

Implications for Policy, Practice, and Personal Judgment

Three implications follow. First, clarity about categories prevents equivocation. Being a human organism, being a bearer of moral rights, and being legally protected are distinct statuses; policy that treats them as identical will drift between premises and conclusions without argument. Second, any serious position must show its work in the hard margins—coma, anencephaly, ectopic pregnancy, and late-gestation conflicts of risks—because that is where criteria reveal their actual commitments. Third, under uncertainty, practical reasoning often shifts to risk management: if one cannot determine with confidence when personhood begins, some argue for a moral presumption against elective abortion early in pregnancy coupled with a legal posture that hesitates to criminalize conduct absent beyond-a-reasonable-doubt culpability. That pairing—moral caution, legal restraint—appears in contemporary philosophical discussion, precisely because it honors both the stakes and the limits of proof.

Where Genuine Disagreement Remains

The live disagreements are not caricatures; they are principled. Proponents of intrinsic value safeguard equality by rejecting capacity tests that could endanger the most vulnerable, but they must confront bodily autonomy with arguments that do not flatten persons into vessels. Autonomy-centered theorists protect the integrity of the self against compulsory use, but they must articulate obligations to dependent humans that do not reduce infancy and severe disability to preference. Moderates seeking thresholds should admit their arbitrariness risk and defend why their chosen line holds beyond convenience or consensus.

What a Durable Resolution Would Require

Durability will not come from a new scan of embryology but from intellectual architecture: a rights-conflict framework that specifies when and why another person’s body may be conscripted, a developmental account that explains why certain milestones matter morally, and a consistency check across edge cases. The best versions of each camp already point in these directions—organismic identity tied to defeasible duties on one side, autonomy bounded by special obligations on the other. Until a framework integrates both moral status and bodily claims without contradiction, the debate will remain what it has long been: a high-stakes argument over which category governs, and why.

Sources:

youtube.com, onlinelibrary.wiley.com, plato.stanford.edu, cambridge.org, irc.rice.edu, abortionarguments.com

Gavin Newsom Caught Admitting The DSA Is Taking Over The Democrat Party

Woke California Governor Gavin Newsom has now admitted that the Democratic Socialists of America would become “dominant” and “a mainstream democratic movement” within the Democratic Party, according to undercover footage obtained by Townhall. The exchange was recorded during an October 17 campaign stop in New Hampshire, where Newsom was supporting Democratic congressional candidate Stefany Shaheen.

An undercover journalist presenting herself as a younger voter asked where the party was headed after saying that young voters wanted more democratic socialist policies. “No one is arguing to manage the status quo and fail more efficiently,” Newsom responded.

He pointed to a demand for bold rather than incremental change, adding, “You can’t play in the margins anymore,” and, “We have to completely reimagine.” Which seems to be a reality most Democrats do not want to admit openly.

Separately, House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries said that removing Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth would be among a Democrat House majority’s first priorities if the party wins control in November. “One of the first things we’re going to do in the majority, we’re going to run Pete Hegseth out of town,” Jeffries declared at a campaign rally.

Speaking to MS NOW afterward, Jeffries said Hegseth “needs to be pushed aside by the president,” warning that Democrats would address the situation if President Donald Trump did not remove him. The White House defended Hegseth, with spokesperson Anna Kelly saying the secretary “is doing a great job leading the Pentagon.”

Sponsor | https://www.purgestore.com | Use promo code DREW for 20% off and support The Gateway Pundit today!

Follow Drew on X: https://x.com/DrewHLive
Follow Drew on Rumble: https://rumble.com/DrewHernandez

The post Gavin Newsom Caught Admitting The DSA Is Taking Over The Democrat Party appeared first on The Gateway Pundit.

Horrific: Paris Rioter Hurls Firebomb Straight into Police Line, Engulfing Officer in Flames During Third Weekend of Violent Chaos (VIDEO)

A violent rioter in Paris hurled a firebomb directly into a line of French riot police on Saturday afternoon, with the device exploding on an officer and covering his shield, helmet, and body in flames as the officer beside him fell backward to the ground.

The rioters have claimed they are protesting the cost of living and school conditions.

The shocking incident unfolded on a city street in the 12th arrondissement near Porte de Charenton during the third consecutive weekend of nationwide riots.

French journalist Luc Auffret captured the attack on video and posted it to X.

WATCH (VIEWER DISCRETION ADVISED):

The Paris police prefecture confirmed that a “hard core of several hundred rioters” at the rear of the authorized march attacked officers with projectiles, including at least one Molotov cocktail, as the demonstration arrived at Porte de Charenton.

Masked individuals dressed in black used hammers to pry up paving stones and hurl them at police, while others launched fireworks.

Officers responded with tear gas and baton charges.

French media outlets, including BFMTV and Entrevue, aired footage of the incendiary device exploding near officers, with reports that at least one officer’s leg was injured by the flames.

The Sun reported that one officer’s left leg burned for roughly 30 seconds after a petrol bomb was thrown over him.

Authorities have estimated roughly 320,000 people protested and rioted across France on Saturday, including about 70,000 in Paris.

Many of the protests remained peaceful, but violence broke out in Paris, Lyon, and other cities.

At Place de la République, trash bins, a kiosk, and a car were set on fire.

The post Horrific: Paris Rioter Hurls Firebomb Straight into Police Line, Engulfing Officer in Flames During Third Weekend of Violent Chaos (VIDEO) appeared first on The Gateway Pundit.

Ilhan Omar Wasn’t Sure What Name to Put on 2009 Marriage Application with Brother-Husband

Ilhan Nur Said Elmi aka Ilhan Omar’s marriage application shows that she apparently wasn’t sure whether she should use her real name or fake name when filling out the application with her brother, Ahmed Nur Said Elmi, in 2009. 

The Department of Justice identified Omar as “Ilhan Nur Said Elmi, a/k/a Ilhan Abdullahi Omar” in a recent court filing, revealing her real name for the first time.

It was later revealed by sources familiar with the investigation that “Ilhan Omar” is a fake alias used by Ilhan Nur Said Elmi to obtain citizenship in the year 2000, live in the country illegally, and run for office.

A former Minnesota federal immigration judge has said this could “call into question” every document she’s ever filled out with her fake name, Ilhan Omar.

Trump has highlighted the bombshell discovery during his recent midterm campaign rallies, saying the Somali fraudster should “immediately resign from Congress.”

Now, it’s being revealed that Omar struggled with whether she would take her the same name as her brother after the marriage, crossing out her name twice in the section labeled “COMPLETE NAMES OF PARTIES AFTER MARRIAGE.”

As seen on the 2009 marriage application obtained by the New York Post from Hennepin County, Minnesota, Omar appeared to write her last name first as “Omar.” She then crossed it out and wrote “Elmi.”

Then she crossed that out and settled on Omar.

Both of them also declare on the form that they are not related to each other by blood or adoption.

Via the New York Post:

Ilhan Nur Said Elmi/Omar’s 2009 marriage application obtained by the New York Post

The federal government is still investigating Nur Said Elmi/Omar in a criminal fraud probe focused on her immigration and potentially her finances.

In a recent court filing, the Justice Department said that the investigation is “ongoing” and “no charging decision has been made,” while urging a federal judge to keep the search warrant under seal this week.

The filing also indicates that the search warrant has not been “fully executed.”

The post Ilhan Omar Wasn’t Sure What Name to Put on 2009 Marriage Application with Brother-Husband appeared first on The Gateway Pundit.

Ivan Raiklin Joins Feds For Freedom To Oppose A SHAM Lawsuit Against Him – (VIDEO)

The non-profit organization, Feds For Freedom (FFF) hosted a press conference during an important hearing for a frivolous lawsuit against Prominent J6 activist, Ivan Raiklin, who was in attendance.

Five years later we are still demanding accountability.

Back in July, Raiklin submitted a request to the DOJ to investigate the Department of Defense for these mandates that threatened the freedoms and liberties of our servicemen and women. Months later we are still waiting for a

Executive Director of FFF, Stephanie Weidle opened up the press conference and told the viewers some information on FFF.

“Feds For Freedom was founded in September, 2021, when employees, contractors, and military service members faced sweeping vaccination mandates that threatened their careers, their livelihoods, and their bodily autonomy,” Weidle told the viewers.

“Since our founding we’ve supported whistleblowers, pursued administrative and legal remedies, challenged adverse personal actions, and worked to preserve evidence of misconduct.”

Weidle then brought up the case, which is known as Adirim v. U.S. Central Intelligence Agency et al.

Dr. Terry Adirim, a doctor and former director of the CIA’s Center for Global Health Services sued Raiklin and CIA, Director John Ratcliffe for alleged “violations of due process, privacy rights, breach of employment contract, and common law/constitutional violations tied to political targeting.”

Adirim filed this lawsuit shortly after being terminated from her position.

“So what is this lawsuit about? In the Spring of 2025, Dr. Terry Adirim was terminated from her position at the CIA. A position she had been placed in just a few months before. She then filed suit including claims of defamation arising from public statements by retired Lt. Colonel, Ivan Raiklin, regarding her role in the Department of Defense’s COVID-19 vaccination policy,” Weidle continued.

“Most of her claims were dismissed early on. What remains includes a defamation claim against Ivan Raiklin. The case proceeded to discovery in August 2026, including her deposition under oath. This lawsuit is significant for a simple reason, Dr. Adirim, the first Department of Defense official to be questioned under oath regarding her role and the implementation of the military COVID-19 vaccine mandate. Feds for Freedom is supporting the defense in pursuit of accountability.”

This case “opens a door that had previously seemed closed.”

Weidle also took the opportunity to bring up the injustices that service members faced during the military vaccine mandates, including vaccine injuries and fatalities.

“A sharp rise in recorded illness and injury across that period. The Department has explained away those figures as a ‘database error,’ yet nobody outside the Department had been permitted to audit them,” Weidle continued.

“On behalf of React-19, on behalf of his mother Korina, I want to tell you about Jeremiah Kruntorad and his army National Guard platoon. Jeremiah was a calvary scout. He left for basic training in January 2021 and grew close to his platoon of fifty. They received the COVID-19 shots in May of 2021. His friend Lindy was paralyzed for eight months after her second dose and has been fighting for her life since.”

“Two other friends committed suicide within six months. Jeremiah took his own life two years later with no prior mental health history. He and at least one other friend died after receiving the same two pfizer batches. Both are recorded as military deaths in the vaccine adverse event reporting system.

Out of fifty service members in the platoon, three took their lives, which accounts for six percent of the platoon.

Physician and biochemist, Robert W Malone then took the stage:

“I am honored to stand here in support of both Ivan and the Feds for Freedom organization. I support a full accounting of the military COVID-19 vaccination mandate and the decisions implemented. Ivan Raiklin has publicly identified Dr. Terry Adirim’s September 14th 2021 memorandum as the instrument that treated the pfizer biotech emergency authorization product as interchangeable with the license comirnaty product and directed it’s use to carry out the mandate,” Malone told the viewers.

Malone highlighted Raiklin’s work in bringing to the public light these corrupt actions of Adirim during her reign in power.

Raiklin publicly identified Adirim’s military vaccine mandate memo as unlawful and in retaliation she initiated the lawsuit against him. Is Raiklin the one being politically targeted here?

Following the press conference, Raiklin took questions from the audience:

While Raiklin continues to seek justice for those negatively affected during the COVID-19 era, the Deep State continues to deflect and paint him out to be the villain in this situation in order to avoid accountability for their own actions.

You can learn more about the case here.

The post Ivan Raiklin Joins Feds For Freedom To Oppose A SHAM Lawsuit Against Him – (VIDEO) appeared first on The Gateway Pundit.

Evil in Our Midst: Twisted Group Proudly Displays Pro-Abortion Artist’s Satanic Statue Outside Southside St. Louis City Office

Shahzia Sikander’s sculpture “Witness” is on display in Madison Square Park as part of her multimedia exhibition “Havah…to breathe, air, life” on February 7, 2023, in New York City. – Pakistani-American artist Shahzia Sikander, whose statues “NOW” and “Witness” stand majestically on the ledge of a neoclassical New York Supreme Court building and in the adjoining Madison Park in Manhattan, wants to raise awareness about the low artistic representation of women in public space and the political, social and economic discrimination they face. (Getty Images)

They are evil and don’t even hide it anymore.

And, this is in St. Louis City in red state Missouri. The traveling statue was previously displayed in New York and Houston.

The “Witness” statue in St. Louis is an 18‑foot golden sculpture by Pakistani-American artist Shahzia Sikander.

The statue was installed at Rung for Women in the Fox Park neighborhood of south St. Louis. It depicts a levitating female figure with braided ram‑horn‑like hair, root‑like arms, and a collar referencing Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg.

Missouri Attorney General Catherine Hanaway had this to say about the satanic statue going up in St. Louis between two statues.

Local FOX 2 reported:

A sculpture that the Missouri Attorney General describes as “demonic” has been installed in south St. Louis.

The sculpture, called “Witness,” now stands outside the Rung For Women organization, which helps women with career development.

Missouri Attorney General Catherine Hanway recently argued on social media that some residents see the sculpture as “demonic affront to faith.”

The artist behind it tells FOX 2 it is inspired by the fight for abortion rights and the overturning of Roe v. Wade in 2022.

The Gateway Foundation is funding the artwork as an example of freedom of expression.

The left is getting more brazen with their open wickedness.

The post Evil in Our Midst: Twisted Group Proudly Displays Pro-Abortion Artist’s Satanic Statue Outside Southside St. Louis City Office appeared first on The Gateway Pundit.

Bus Driver Who Wore Pink Schoolgirl Outfit and Named His Route the ‘Lolita Line’ Files Human Rights Complaint After Being Confronted by Parents and Fired (VIDEO)

A deranged transgender biological male school bus driver in Ontario who was removed from his route after parents filmed him wearing a pink schoolgirl uniform and displaying a “Lolita Line” sign on his bus has filed a human rights complaint alleging discrimination.

The driver, identified in tribunal documents only by the initials L.Z., worked for Landmark Bus Lines transporting students to St. Michael the Archangel Catholic Elementary School in Woodbridge.

As The Gateway Pundit previously reported, in 2025, parents confronted him outside the school while he stood in the bus doorway dressed in a short pink skirt, white frilly blouse with a large bow, thigh-high stockings, and a headband, with a paper sign in the windshield reading “Lolita Line.”

“You picked up the kids dressed like that?” a parent can be heard asking in a video of the confrontation.

The driver replied, “I do this every day, and I don’t think… there is an issue.”

“So you pulled out, you picked up the kids dressed like that?” a parent asks again.

The driver responds, “Yep.”

“Why is it called the Lolita Line?” a parent demanded.

The driver did not respond.

WATCH:

@6ixbuzztv Are the parents overreacting? Let us know in the comments! v.the_light/IG #6ixbuzz #toronto #torontotiktok #fyp ♬ original sound – 6ixbuzzTV

The “Lolita Line” reference drew particular concern because the term is widely associated with Vladimir Nabokov’s novel about an adult man’s sexual obsession with a 12-year-old girl. It is often used in the sexualization of children.

The York Catholic District School Board notified Landmark Bus Lines about the behavior, which removed the driver from the route and assured the board he would not be assigned to any of its schools going forward.

Board communications described the matter as resolved.

L.Z. has now filed a complaint with the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario against both Landmark Bus Lines and the York Catholic District School Board, claiming discrimination on the basis of ethnic origin, gender identity, and sex.

He sought and received a publication ban protecting his identity, which the tribunal granted on October 13, citing his identifying as a “transgender woman” and concerns about backlash from negative media attention.

“The applicant argues that the only thing that has kept her safe is that her name and personal details have not been revealed,” the order states. “The applicant states that the events in the Application have been publicized in a manner that described her as a danger to the public because of her gender identity and negative stereotypes that have been associated with her identity.

“In addition, the applicant submits that she would be at risk of physical harm, intimidation, and harassment based on the commentary on social media and news outlets, if her identity and personal information are made public.”

Jamie Sarkonak of the National Post reported that the case only became public because of the publication ban request.

The report states:

The human rights complaint would have proceeded in secret were it not for L.Z.’s insistence on securing a publication ban, which was granted on Oct. 13. The Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario does not post upcoming hearings online, unlike its more transparent cousins in B.C., Alberta and Manitoba, so there would have been no realistic way for the public to know that it was on the docket.

The tribunal did, however, publish its decision to grant a publication ban protecting L.Z.’s identity on Oct. 23. According to the decision, L.Z. wanted a publication ban because “she is a transgender woman” and because the events at the heart of the complaint “have garnered negative media attention.”

“The applicant has faced threats to her safety and discriminatory labels due to transphobic stereotypes,” adds the decision.

It’s unclear whether this individual is mentally ill, simply engaging in a stunt to take advantage of an overzealous, unaccountable human rights system, or something else altogether. No rational adult would show up to a job with proximity to kids in a skimpy costume and a reference to a novel about the sexual abuse of a child by a middle-aged man … and then revive the controversy by engaging in lawfare.

No hearing date has been set at the time of publication.

The post Bus Driver Who Wore Pink Schoolgirl Outfit and Named His Route the ‘Lolita Line’ Files Human Rights Complaint After Being Confronted by Parents and Fired (VIDEO) appeared first on The Gateway Pundit.

DEATH CULT: Deranged Iowa Baker Sells Halloween Tombstone Cookies Marked ‘DJT,’ Vampire ‘BITE ICE,’ and ‘8647’ Designs

A home-based bakery in Grimes, Iowa, called Sweetems Co. by Justina is drawing widespread backlash after selling gray tombstone-shaped Halloween cookies iced with “DJT,” “FDT,” and the phrase “Any Day Now,” complete with cobweb frosting.

The bakery is run by Justina Rucinski, who has previously produced other anti-Trump cookie designs, including ones captioned “Orange Lies Matter” and messages related to “No Kings” protests.

Rucinski has previously appeared on Food Network’s Christmas Cookie Challenge.

Libs of TikTok posted a photo of the cookies on Thursday, writing, “ATTENTION EVERYONE IN IOWA. This bakery is selling tombstone cookies with Trump’s name and the words ‘any day now.’ It’s a death cult.”

The baker is also making cookies featuring Trump as a dead cartoon corpse, a vampire “BITE ICE” design, “8647” on a frosted Frankenstein, and more.

 

 

Rucinski has publicly stated she will not fulfill pro-Trump orders, though it is unclear what pro-Trump customers she thinks she may have.

After the Libs of TikTok post, Rucinski responded on her business page with “So much support,” reveling in the attention.

Rucinski’s upcoming Christmas cookies feature a black Mrs. Claus with “F-ck Trump” hidden in her hair design, a cookie iced with “Jesus wasn’t white,” Santa holding a “Believe Women” sign, and “IHDY?,” which leftists use to ask, “Is he dead yet?” referring to the president.

The post DEATH CULT: Deranged Iowa Baker Sells Halloween Tombstone Cookies Marked ‘DJT,’ Vampire ‘BITE ICE,’ and ‘8647’ Designs appeared first on The Gateway Pundit.

US Attorney in Arizona Investigating Three Leftwing Groups for Registering Non-Citizens After Muckraker Report on Pro-Katie Hobbs Groups – Matter Referred to the FBI

The US Attorney for the District of Arizona has opened an investigation into three leftwing nonprofits in Arizona for “registering non-citizens to vote in Arizona.”

The three groups under investigation are Stand Indivisible Arizona and Worker Power, two nonprofit groups backing Arizona Governor Katie Hobbs and other Democratic candidates, and When We Count, the Democratic National Committee’s own national voter registration program.

“The United States Attorney’s Office has already referred the matter to the FBI for a thorough federal investigation,” US Attorney Timothy Courchaine’s office announced in a press release.

This comes after Muckraker released a report, featuring volunteers from the three organizations attempting to register undercover journalists posing as non-citizens and felons.

When Katie Hobbs was asked about the groups’ attempts to cheat, she ran away from questions.

MUST WATCH: Katie Hobbs Canvassers Busted by Muckraker Trying to Register Felons and Noncitizens to Vote – Hobbs RUNS When Confronted!

In letters to Democratic Arizona Secretary of State Adrian Fontes and Republican Maricopa County Recorder Justin Heap, US Attorney Timothy Courchaine writes, “Based on written and video reports, personnel acting on behalf of the following organizations either intentionally disregarded or were recklessly ignorant of Arizona’s law prohibiting the registration of non-citizens in elections.”

“Based on a cursory review, it appears these organizations and their volunteers or employees may have violated A.R.S. § 16-182 by knowingly causing or procuring another person to be registered while knowing that person is not entitled to register to vote,” he continues, requesting a review of voter registrations submitted by the three groups.

Courchaine’s office said in a press release on Friday,

PHOENIX, Ariz. – Today, U.S. Attorney Timothy Courchaine announced that his office has opened a case into recent reporting about three non-profit organizations registering non-citizens to vote in Arizona. The United States Attorney’s Office has already referred the matter to the FBI for a thorough federal investigation.

On Monday, Oct. 26, U.S. Attorney Courchaine also sent letters to the Maricopa County Recorder and Arizona Secretary of State, expressing concerns about the recent reporting and encouraging those offices to review voter registrations associated with the accused non-profit organizations.

On the eve of an important midterm election, the District of Arizona reminds the public that voting is limited solely to U.S. citizens. If you are a non-citizen, you may not vote in Tuesday’s election, even if you have legal authority to be in the country on a visa or as a legal permanent resident. Further, knowingly causing another person to be registered to vote while knowing that person is not entitled to do so would violate federal law.

The post US Attorney in Arizona Investigating Three Leftwing Groups for Registering Non-Citizens After Muckraker Report on Pro-Katie Hobbs Groups – Matter Referred to the FBI appeared first on The Gateway Pundit.

Democrat Rep. Jim Hines Threatens Elon Musk, Says Democrats Have War Gamed Fantasy Violent Election Day Chaos Caused by Musk Manipulating Algorithms That Causes Armed Citizens to Attack Polling Places

Democrats have war-gamed potential Election Day chaos that includes armed groups attacking polling places after being manipulated by Elon Musk, according to Rep. Jim Himes (D-CT) in remarks to the left-wing news site MeidasTouch published Friday.

Himes threatened X social media site owner Musk, saying, “I’m looking at you here, Elon Musk…We’re watching very closely.”

Himes speculated that Musk could manipulate algorithms to spread rumors about illegal aliens voting that would provoke armed groups to attack polling places, giving President Donald Trump the opportunity to bring in federal law enforcement.

Himes, who has served in Congress since 2009, is the ranking member of the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence.

Himes said the group that ran the war game included Rep. Jamie Raskin (D-MD), Rep. Joe Morelle (D-NY), lawyers, and nonprofit groups.

Himes noted Musk has spent hundreds of millions of dollars to support Republicans this election and owns X. Himes said Musk or others could spread false rumors or manipulate algorithms to stir up chaos and violence.

Transcript:

Jamie and I, again with Joe Morelle and others, and lawyers and as he said nonprofits, we’ve, we’ve, we’ve wargamed a lot of these scenarios and one of these scenarios, and I’m looking at you here Elon Musk because you know, he in particular has been a massive financial player in this election. Hundreds of millions of dollars of his own fortune has gone into supporting Republican candidates. And of course he controls a major social media platform uh, X, what used to be Twitter.

And one of the scenarios we gamed out is that one of these lords of, uh, of technology decides in the middle of the day to start propagating misinformation to, and again there’s a thousand scenarios here none of which are particularly happy to contemplate, but one of them is that Elon Musk and I don’t mean to, you know, say he’s the one who’s going to do this, but he certainly has the power to alter those algor, algorithms or to tell a story that is false, you know, to say that reports in Michigan are that massive numbers of the undocumented are voting in the election. And in that moment, this is an opportunity to manipulate people. And if a whole bunch of guys with guns in Michigan see a bunch of social media posts that suggest falsely that, you know, the undocumented are, are, are voting in Detroit, the you know, what’s to stop them from jumping into trucks armed and showing up at polling places?

Now local police are overwhelmed and you know, heaven forbid there’s some sort of violence and the local police are overwhelmed. What do you think the president’s going to do? Well, he’s going to send in federal uh, law enforcement.

So, um again, um I, I, I don’t want to suggest that that is absolutely the scenario that is going to happen, but you can’t be too suspicious or prepared. And so, you know, we have been in contact with um, uh, these many leaders who do not have the benefit of the doubt these days to say, you know, we’re watching very closely. There are, more importantly, there are lawyers who are watching very uh, closely about whether you take any steps that are either aggressive against uh, the proper functioning of our democracy or negligent.”

The complete interview can be viewed here:

Host Ben Meislas opened by speaking about the paranoid fears of a friend who said Trump and Republicans are going to rig the election and not honor the results.

Himes recalled Trump challenging the 2020 election results and said he fears Trump could say the Iranians hacked election machines, so he has used his position on the House Intelligence Committee to try to prevent that. Himes also said the has received classified briefings this week that informed him there is no evidence any foreign country is planning, has the intent or the ability to “mess around with the mechanics” of the election.

Transcript:

You asked me the question first. So, as the ranking member of the Intelligence Committee, my job is to just be all over the possibility that of the many, many scenarios that he may choose to use on election day, one of them may be a variant of the director of the CIA has just informed me that the Iranians have taken control over the election apparatus in Michigan or North Carolina or Florida or California, whatever it might be.

Um, because of course that would be something that would be very much in the jurisdiction of the intelligence committee, I have spent the last couple of months working with our intelligence community, working with the remnants of our ability to identify such efforts to make sure that we’re ready for that. Um, and you know, Jamie can elaborate on this on the domestic side because of course the FBI and the Department of Justice are as much of a threat and there’s lots of things the president could do to create tension in the moment of, of, of of election day.

But um, I, I, I, want to finish my answer by saying um I’ve had classified briefings as recently as seventy-two hours ago. And not only have we never seen a successful effort on the part of Russia or China or or any other country to interfere with our election, that is to alter vote totals to get into voting um records to get into the voting roles. We’re not seeing any foreign country at this point planning or even with the ability to do so. Now draw a distinction, of course there they are they are doing influence operations. You know the usual garbage on social media and bots trying to influence the election. But as of now our intelligence community is seeing precisely zero evidence that any of uh, you know, Russia or China or Iran or North Korea have any intent or ability to actually mess around with the mechanics of our election.

The post Democrat Rep. Jim Hines Threatens Elon Musk, Says Democrats Have War Gamed Fantasy Violent Election Day Chaos Caused by Musk Manipulating Algorithms That Causes Armed Citizens to Attack Polling Places appeared first on The Gateway Pundit.